What’s old is new again: Fresh speculation about defining ultra-processed foods

Washington is (once again) in a tizzy over whether the Trump administration might (but probably will not) release the ultra-processed foods definition before the election.


Happy Friday, and welcome to Food Fix. If you happen to find yourself in New York City next week, you should come to our live-taping of the Forked podcast!

Free tix alert: Forked is hosting a live podcast taping at the Brooklyn Museum with special guest Tom Colicchio next Wednesday, Nov. 4. We’ll talk about the restaurant biz, Colicchio’s experience lobbying on food issues, the MAHA movement and, of course, the midterm elections. A select number of comped tickets just dropped, so get your free ticket while they last! 

Don’t miss out: The best way to make sure you don’t miss a beat in food policy is to upgrade to a paid subscription and get Food Fix in your inbox twice per week. Almost everyone who upgrades finds it valuable. This week, I wrote about the Trump administration’s “Make Hospital Food Healthier Pledge.” Upgrade today. 

As always, I welcome your feedback. Send me your thoughts by replying to this email, or drop me a line: helena@foodfix.co. 

Alright, let’s get to it –

Helena

 
***

What’s old is new again: Fresh speculation about defining ultra-processed foods


Waiting for the Trump administration’s draft definition for ultra-processed foods (UPFs) to drop (or not) is starting to feel a bit like the movie Groundhog Day.

One week the definition seems on the precipice of release. The next, the effort is near dead — buried under relentless lobbying from food industry interests who absolutely do not want it to see the light of day, not this week, not next week, not ever. 

We’ve been on this timeloop rollercoaster for months now. Back in March, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. told podcaster Joe Rogan the definition would be out by April. It wasn’t. 

In June, Kennedy said the UPF definition was done — under review at the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and would be out within a few months. It wasn’t done, it wasn’t at OMB, and it wasn’t out within a few months. 

In August, we expected HHS to unveil a draft definition at a policy celebration. That didn’t happen, either. Intense pushback from industry scuttled the plan at the eleventh hour. Instead of being publicly released, the draft definition was sent to OMB for review. Since then, OMB has been barraged with meeting requests about the definition, largely from industry groups, but plenty of consumer and health groups are making their case, too. (I wrote about all this a couple weeks ago — and since then there have been even more meetings!)

If you’re wondering why there is so much fighting over a definition (sounds toothless and technically it is!)… Well, food companies are pretty worried that a federal definition will be used to make policies targeting their products. And, ultimately, a definition could make it much easier for plaintiffs’ lawyers (and state attorneys general) to sue them because the poor health outcomes tied to UPF consumption are extremely costly.

A recent analysis from the University of Chicago found that if FDA were to require front-of-pack labels for UPFs, for example, it would cost the food industry $14 billion per year. 

Per Food Dive: “A labeling mandate would apply to 72 percent of packaged foods and encompass 51 percent of consumers’ grocery spending, the study said…As more Americans become aware of ultraprocessed foods and seek to avoid them, health experts say a definition would be the first step in giving consumers more guidance as they make choices about their diet.” (To be clear, Kennedy has previously said he wants to use the UPF definition in a front-of-pack labeling effort, but actually doing this would be a huge lift.)

Listen up: While we’re here, if you want to dive into the case for defining ultra-processed foods, this week’s episode of American Dish is an interview with two of the key leaders in this space: Dariush Mozaffarian with Tufts University and Lindsey Smith Taillie with UNC Chapel Hill.

Midterm mania: In recent weeks, there’s been a last ditch effort by Kennedy and his allies to fling the UPF definition free ahead of the midterms, as first reported by Politico. You may recall just last week top Kennedy advisor Calley Means resigned from the administration, reportedly over frustrations about key parts of the MAHA agenda being blocked by the White House. The endless delay over the UPF definition was seen as the last straw. After all that, the push to get the UPF definition out seemed to be fully dead last week. 

But no! I found myself back in the timeloop this week as it became clear that Kennedy has been making another late-game push to try to get the White House to release the definition in the final days ahead of the midterms. This sent food industry folks into yet another tizzy behind the scenes. 

Insiders expect Kennedy to meet with White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles today about all of this, though no one I’ve talked to thinks the meeting is likely to change much. (The White House didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.)

At the end of the day, it appears that the White House is not likely to bend to Kennedy on this, at least not right now — food and ag industry interests have been screaming about this effort for months, and the message has been received. MAHA allies are worried that if the UPF definition doesn’t come out before the midterms it won’t come out at all. For now, the will-they-won’t-they rollercoaster continues. 

Dwindling agenda: If you zoom out, the fight over defining UPF (which is not a regulation, though it could one day be used for one) is just the latest example of the dwindling of the MAHA agenda. 

Kennedy has repeatedly said ultra-processed foods are the main driver of chronic disease among children, but even defining these foods is apparently out of reach (forget enacting any policies that crack down on them). Kennedy has repeatedly told the American people that we’re being “poisoned” by our food, but the agencies under his purview have not banned a single food chemical of concern. Rank-and-file MAHA supporters have already spent most of this year absolutely furious about the Trump administration’s decidedly industry-friendly approach to pesticides, pollution and even pharma. The White House has maintained throughout that the commitment to MAHA remains, but actions speak louder than words. 


***

What I’m reading


FDA proposes new nutrient limits, labeling rules for infant formula (Reuters). “The US FDA proposed new nutrient limits and labeling rules for infant formula on ​Thursday, as part of its ongoing review of ‌baby formula nutrients,” reports Sneha S K. “The FDA launched ‘Operation Stork Speed’ last year, which began a nutrient review process and increased testing for heavy metals and ​other contaminants in infant formula, while also urging ​companies to develop new products. The ⁠rule, if finalized, will amend limits for four required ​nutrients — iodine, vitamin A, vitamin D, and manganese — and establish ​a maximum level for manganese. It would also change how vitamins A and D are measured, allow a new source of vitamin ​A and revise labeling requirements. The agency assessed four additional ​nutrients — chloride, selenium, potassium, and sodium — and concluded that current required levels ‌were ⁠appropriate. FDA has urged the infant-formula industry and supply-chain partners to exercise substantive oversight of their suppliers following several product recalls and recent infant botulism cases.”

ByHeart executives to buy Perrigo’s infant formula business (Bloomberg). “A company led by executives of ByHeart, the infant-formula maker whose product sickened dozens of babies with botulism last year, will buy Perrigo Co.’s infant-formula business for up to $175 million, Perrigo said Thursday,” reports Anna Edney. Ron Belldegrun and Mia Funt, a brother and sister who co-founded ByHeart, are now chief executive officer and president, respectively, of MeridianMade, a contract manufacturing company. Dublin-based Perrigo is the maker of store-brand formulas. Funt’s LinkedIn profile indicates she stopped working at ByHeart in July. A spokesperson for MeridianMade said ByHeart has been ‘discontinued’ and won’t relaunch.”

Kennedy’s closing arguments for the 2026 midterms: Fraud, vaccines, and MAHA (STAT). “On Wednesday night in Clive, Iowa, a parade of MAHA activists and Republican candidates decried Big Agriculture, stressed the rise in chronic disease in America, and called for the Covid-19 vaccine to be removed from the market,” Chelsea Cirruzzo reports. “Among them, Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, who made inaccurate claims about the hepatitis B vaccine; Michael Boes, the chief MAHA officer at Steak ’n Shake, who called the MAHA movement a ‘catalyst for a monumental shift;’ and Moms Across America founder Zen Honeycutt, who called for the end of liability shields for pesticide and pharmaceutical companies. The rally was being held for Zach Lahn, the unlikely farmer-turned-Republican candidate for Iowa governor, but speakers spent a lot of their time teeing up the night’s main attraction: health secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has been an ardent Lahn supporter.” 

C.D.C. deputy director resigns after four months in the job (New York Times). “Dr. Jennifer Shuford, a former state health commissioner whom President Trump appointed to a top post at the CDC to help steady the agency, is leaving after just four months in the job,” reports Apoorva Mandavilli. “Dr. Shuford’s last day is planned for Nov. 12, the C.D.C. said in a statement on Tuesday. Her departure was reported Monday night by The Washington Post. Dr. Erica Schwartz, the C.D.C. director, announced the news to staff in an email Tuesday morning. News of Dr. Shuford’s exit comes as the C.D.C. faces criticism over its response to unrelenting measles outbreaks in the country. The agency is embroiled in a dispute over its refusal to acknowledge several measles-related deaths reported by the Pennsylvania Health Department.” 

DoorDash is buying Instacart for $17 billion (CNN). “DoorDash is buying rival Instacart in a deal worth roughly $17 billion, signaling that the delivery wars continue to heat up,” reports Jordan Valinsky. “The deal, announced Thursday, marks an end for Instacart as an independent company. Instacart went public in 2023 and benefited from a pandemic-era boom for the grocery delivery service, but it has struggled to maintain its momentum against larger competitors, like Uber, Amazon and Walmart. Combining Instacart and DoorDash would create a larger company that better competes with those rivals.”

Dolores Huerta, labor leader and force for civil rights, has died (New York Times). “Dolores Huerta, who with Cesar Chavez founded what became the United Farm Workers and led strikes and boycotts in the 1960s and ’70s that unionized many California table-grape growers, changing laws and the lives of thousands of migrant laborers, died on Wednesday at her home in Bakersfield, Calif.,” Robert D. McFadden reports. “She was 96. The cause of death was cancer, Erik Olvera, a spokesman for her family, said. Ms. Huerta, who became a kind of Mexican American folk hero, depicted in murals and ballads, was the union’s vice president for nearly four decades and, until Mr. Chavez’s death in 1993, his second-in-command. He was the charismatic — and, it was later revealed, abusive — leader; she, the skilled organizer who coordinated walkouts and boycotts under a black Aztec eagle banner and negotiated pathbreaking contracts with agribusiness.”

Dollar General sued over alleged overcharges (Civil Eats). “The Federal Trade Commission along with 20 states filed a lawsuit against the Dollar General Corporation yesterday for allegedly charging customers more than the price displayed on shelves,” Rebekah Alvey reports. “Dollar General operates more than 21,000 stores across the country. Many of these are found in rural areas and food deserts, where they are only nearby grocery option. The complaint alleges the chain has knowingly mislabeled prices and overcharged customers for years, and that, despite tens of thousands of complaints from customers regarding mislabeled products, Dollar General did not respond or work to rectify the problem. The company entered into settlements with six state attorneys general and consumer protection agencies between 2019 and 2026 regarding these claims. In total, Dollar General has paid $6 million in penalties.”


***

Why you should upgrade to a paid Food Fix subscription


Become a paid subscriber to unlock access to two newsletters each week, packed with insight, analysis and exclusive reporting on what’s happening in food, in Washington and beyond. You’ll also get full access to the Food Fix archive — a great way to get smart on all things food policy.

Expense it: Most paid subscribers expense their subscriptions through work. It’s worth asking! 

Discounts: We also offer discounts for government, academia and students. See our subscription options. Individuals who participate in SNAP or other federal nutrition programs qualify for a free Food Fix subscription — just email info@foodfix.co. 

Get the Friday newsletter: If someone forwarded you this email, sign yourself up for the free Friday edition of Food Fix. You can also follow Food Fix on X, Bluesky and LinkedIn.

See you again next week!